Criminal Justice And Human Rights Law Blog
I publish an "Editorial and Opinion Blog", Editorial and Opinion . I have a Jazz Blog @ Jazz and a Technology Blog @ Technology.
What To Do When You're Stopped By Police - The ACLU & Elon James White
Know Anyone Who Thinks Racial Profiling Is Exaggerated? Watch This, And Tell Me When Your Jaw Drops.
This video clearly demonstrates how racist America is as a country and how far we have to go to become a country that is civilized and actually values equal justice. We must not rest until this goal is achieved. I do not want my great grandchildren to live in a country like we have today. I wish for them to live in a country where differences of race and culture are not ignored but valued as a part of what makes America great.
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
‘I’m heartbroken’: experts dismayed as US loses long-held measles elimination status
‘I’m heartbroken’: experts dismayed as US loses long-held measles elimination status
The US lost its 26-year measles elimination status, joining Bolivia and Mexico in resurgence. Amid the worst outbreak since 1991, health leaders expressed grief and condemned the Trump administration. Calls for Health Secretary Kennedy’s resignation intensified, though he pledged to regain status and recommend MMR vaccines.
Public health leaders condemn ‘significant damage’ by Trump administration as calls grow for RFK Jr to resign

Doctors and public health leaders expressed grief and alarm at the loss of US measles-free status, a hard-won public health victory that once made the US a leader in infectious disease elimination.
Measles was declared resurgent in the United States, Bolivia and Mexico by the Pan American Health Organization (Paho) on Tuesday, meaning the virus has spread continuously for 12 months.
The announcement formally ends a 26-year record of measles elimination in the US, and comes amid the worst measles outbreak since 1991, making the loss of measles elimination status widely predicted. The Americas were once the only measles-free World Health Organization (WHO) region on the globe.
“There’s no question it was emotional, because we’ve been working on this initiative for decades,” Dr Jon Andrus, the chair of the Paho advisory committee that recommended the US lose its measles elimination status, told the Guardian.
“To see the US, once a global leader, lose its status is of course sad,” Andrus continued, citing the work of friends and colleagues, “and it was also sad to see our Mexican colleagues lose their status, as well as Bolivia.”
That grief was in sharp contrast to the reaction of the Trump administration. Health secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr, who has spent years spreading misinformation about the measles, mumps and rubella combination vaccine (MMR) and downplaying the disease, had his agency promote an appearance with a Texas-based chef and posted a picture of himself as James Bond this week. After devastating midterm losses, Trump appointed Maha advocate Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff.
Measles elimination status is a public health designation. It does not come with penalties or travel restrictions. Instead, it is a project of public health workers, from localities to international officials, who rank vaccination among the most cost-effective ways to improve human life, an intervention ranked alongside public sanitation and clean drinking water.
“There’s a huge return on investment that is pretty amazing,” said Andrus.
The loss of elimination status has already heightened calls for Kennedy to be fired – including from critical swing vote senators such as Republican Bill Cassidy of Louisiana. On Sunday, Cassidy called Kennedy’s tenure as health secretary “a series of failures”. Democratic senator of Georgia Raphael Warnock criticized Kennedy for posting “AI slop” when the US lost its measles-free status.
For his part, Kennedy said in a statement posted on X late on Tuesday afternoon that the US “will stop measles outbreaks, protect American families, and work to regain US measles elimination status”.
He added that he would “continue to recommend MMR vaccination as the most effective way to prevent measles” and that officials with the Department of Health and Human Services “are working to close vaccination gaps and rebuild public trust. We will answer families’ questions honestly about vaccine benefits and risks and work with trusted health care providers and community leaders to prevent measles, limit its spread, and support timely treatment.”
The US is in the midst of the worst measles outbreak in decades, with more than 5,400 cases and 10 measles-associated deaths reported by state health authorities. Measles is considered one of the most infectious diseases known to medicine. The infection kills one to three unvaccinated people per 1,000 and hospitalizes up to one in five.
“The measles virus is not harmless,” said American Academy of Pediatrics President Dr Andrew D Racine. “It can cause pneumonia, hospitalization, brain damage and death. We have an extraordinary tool to prevent it: a safe, effective, inexpensive, and readily available vaccine.”
Notably, the worst of this year’s outbreak would not have even been considered by Andrus and colleagues at Paho, since the group only examined data from the first half of 2026. The announcement was nevertheless widely predicted and even leaked. It comes amid a global resurgence in measles that saw Canada lose its measles-free status in 2025, and the UK this year.
“As a pediatrician and a parent, I am heartbroken that we have reached this point,” Dr Richard Besser, president and CEO of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, and a former acting director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), said in a statement.
“Medical providers and state, local, and tribal health officials across America are doing what they can to stop current measles outbreaks and prevent new ones,” said Besser. “Yet for the past two years, the federal government has largely been missing in action. That needs to change. It is no surprise that the resurgence of measles has coincided with an administration that has inflicted significant damage to our healthcare system while spreading false claims about vaccines.”
Democratic senator-elect Dr Annie Andrews of South Carolina, a critic of Kennedy and one of several newly elected doctors and scientists, told the Guardian: “We need to restore trust in public health, make sure every family has access to life-saving vaccines, and put the health and safety of our children ahead of our politics.”
Health experts also called on the US to begin work on an action plan for Paho, one that could help the US stop transmission and make gains in vaccination. Considered a multi-year project, Brazil lost measles-free status in 2019 and regained it five years later. On Tuesday, Paho announced that Canada had stopped transmission for 60 days, a step toward regaining its measles-free status.
As measles spreads in the US, Americans face a new reality where pockets of low vaccination rates can combust into outbreaks. In places such as Cleveland, Ohio, a nearby outbreak has spurred the local public health director to tell residents to find decades-old vaccination certificates, lest they be exposed and require a blood draw or quarantine.
“Because measles is so contagious, it’s considered a bellwether, a signal of problems in efforts to control disease,” epidemiologist Gregg Gonsalves, a Yale researcher who serves on the coordinating committee for advocacy group Defend Public Health, said in a statement.
“RFK Jr has spent over a decade trying to destroy disease prevention, the last two as HHS secretary, and his public health malpractice is coming home to roost.
“Congress can no longer sit back and twiddle its thumbs.”
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Monday, November 16, 2026
Sunday, November 15, 2026
Saturday, November 14, 2026
Friday, November 13, 2026
Democrats fumbled the Hegseth impeachment. That could be a blessing in disguise | Claire Finkelstein
Democrats fumbled the Hegseth impeachment. That could be a blessing in disguise | Claire Finkelstein
“House Republicans scuttled Massie’s impeachment articles against Hegseth, but Democrats may refocus charges. Potential bipartisan articles include mishandling classified communications, Caribbean and Pacific boat strikes, and retribution against Mark Kelly. Impeachment could also investigate Pentagon lawyers and strengthen congressional oversight.
A traffic jam, combined with disorganization on the part of Democrats, enabled House Republicans to scuttle the representative Thomas Massie’s articles of impeachment against Pete Hegseth on Wednesday.
While recriminations are now flying among Democrats, the fumble may have been a blessing in disguise. Democrats can now refocus the articles against the defense secretary, possibly to better effect.
The first four of Massie’s articles of impeachment addressed the Iran war, asserting that the Department of Defense overstepped presidential war powers authority. The first three accused Hegseth of failing to respect congressional authority and the War Powers Resolution. And the fourth claimed that that the Pentagon failed to mitigate harm to civilians in its operations, resulting in the tragedy of the US strike on the girls’ school in Minab, Iran.
Inclusion of the first four articles of impeachment, however, might ultimately have backfired in the Senate, and maybe even in the House in the final vote.
The US has a long history of presidents ignoring Congress’s role in decisions to engage in military force. From Nixon’s invasion of Laos and Cambodia, to US-led Nato intervention in Kosovo and Serbia under Bill Clinton, to US military intervention in Libya under Barack Obama, among others, presidents and their secretaries of defense have flouted Congress’s role in authorizing military operations for years.
The same can be said about harm to civilians in US operations. It was mistaken strikes against civilians during the Obama years that inspired Secretary Mattis, followed by Secretary Austin, to establish the now-shuttered Civilian Harm Mitigation and Response program. Dismantling the program was a Hegseth initiative and one of Massie’s concerns.
A more targeted set of articles in the new Congress might stand a better chance of success.
Three causes for impeachment stand out as most likely to garner bipartisan support. The first is one that did not even appear in Massie’s articles: Hegseth’s egregious handling of classified communications in the infamous Signal chat conversation regarding a planned military operation in Yemen, when the editor-in-chief of the Atlantic, Jeffrey Goldberg, was inadvertently included on the thread.
“Signalgate”, as it has been called, identifies one of the worst cases of mishandling classified information ever to occur by a higher-level official in the defense department. A Pentagon report itself suggests that Hegseth put troops in danger in this incident.
Hegseth and other members of the administration continued to exchangeclassified information on Signal even after the initial revelation by the Atlantic. Hegseth then embarked on extensive internal investigations, using polygraph testing to search for leakers, and ultimately firing Lt Gen Brett Sylvia, a member of the joint staff. Yet the secretary himself, or at least his lax practices, may well have been the source of some of the very leaks he is investigating.
Second, boat strikes directed against civilian vessels in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific stand on a different footing from the articles relating to the Iran war. This use of US military force has been virtually unanimously condemned by legal experts as an indisputable violation of the laws of war, or, more accurately, as murder.
Third, an article of impeachment addressing the vindictive campaign of retribution against the senator Mark Kelly for a controversial video he made with five other members of Congress could well garner support from Republicans, some of whom may rise to the occasion to defend their colleague.
As I made clear in a brief in support of Mark Kelly, the video, which reminded troops they may refuse to follow illegal orders, merely restated textbook training to servicemembers regarding the law of superior orders. The attack on Kelly was not popular with either Democratic or Republican members of Congress.
As I recently wrote about possible impeachment charges against Trump, Congress’s heightened investigatory powers during an impeachment inquiry provide a critical benefit of the process.
A Hegseth impeachment could force release of the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) memo justifying the boat strikes. OLC lawyers should be called on to testify – presumably behind closed doors – to explain the process by which they came to support the strikes.
An investigation of the OLC is long overdue in any event, and a more general inquiry should be conducted by the House and Senate judiciary committees.
Hegseth’s attack on Pentagon lawyers should also be investigated and should possibly form a fourth article in newly refocused impeachment charges against him.
Starting with the firing of the top Judge Advocate Generals and moving on to incursions into the role played by rank-and-file Jags, Hegseth has sought to undermine fidelity to the rule of law and the role of lawyers in reviewing military operations.
While Congress has heard some testimony on these matters, such as that of Adm Frank Bradley, who took the hit himself for certain of the boat strikes in a likely attempt to protect Hegseth, many questions remain unanswered.
Most critically, impeachment proceedings against Hegseth will provide an opportunity for Congress to strengthen its oversight authority.
Hegseth will likely invoke either presidential “testimonial immunity” or “deliberative privilege”, doctrines made up by the executive branch over time that have rarely been tested in article III courts.
While it is true that presidents need to be able to consult with members of their cabinets confidentially without fear of public revelation, these doctrines have served more to interfere with congressional oversight and block transparency than to further sound presidential decision-making. Congress must work to cut these outsized claims of presidential authority down to size.
There will also likely be assertions that information cannot be shared with Congress due to classification concerns.
Here, too, Congress must stand firm and focus on rebuilding its oversight authority. Members of the two armed services committees have robust classification privileges that make sharing information with Congress behind closed doors entirely legal and appropriate.
Leaders of the 120th Congress will have the opportunity to lead critical impeachment inquiries as well as conduct extensive oversight in the new year, but they must play their cards carefully and keep their eyes on the prize – long-term restoration of democratic norms and the strengthening of checks and balances in the federal government.
Claire Finkelstein, a contributing opinion writer for the Guardian, is the Algernon Biddle professor of law and professor of philosophy at the University of Pennsylvania. She is also the founder and faculty director of Penn’s Center for Ethics and the Rule of Law (CERL). She is a fellow in residence at the Edmond & Lily Safra Center for Ethics at Harvard University during the 2026-27 academic year“
Thursday, November 12, 2026
Wednesday, November 11, 2026
How a Misquote by a Supreme Court Justice Imperils Gun Restrictions
How a Misquote by a Supreme Court Justice Imperils Gun Restrictions
“A 2008 Supreme Court misquote of Blackstone replaced “dangerous or unusual” with “dangerous and unusual,” creating a conjunctive test. This precedent has influenced 98 cases, overturning 20 restrictions. The Supreme Court will soon review assault-weapon bans.

A Supreme Court decision in 2008 case incorrectly quoted a centuries-old legal treatise, with profound implications for today’s gun-control laws.
When the Supreme Court begins weighing the constitutionality of assault-weapons bans next month, the justices will be guided by the court’s own precedent: a landmark ruling that such restrictions are allowed only if a firearm is both “dangerous and unusual.”
For nearly two decades, judges across the country have invoked this language to strike down gun-control laws. It is a pivotal legal test.
It is also based on a misquote.
Justice Antonin Scalia, writing for the majority in the 2008 case, District of Columbia v. Heller, attributed the “dangerous and unusual” language to Sir William Blackstone, an 18th-century English jurist whose writings became the basis for much of American law.
But in his seminal 1769 treatise, “Commentaries on the Laws of England,” Blackstone referred to weapons that were “dangerous or unusual,”suggesting that a gun did not need to be both in order to be restricted.
The consequences of Justice Scalia’s use of “and” rather than “or” have been profound. Since all guns are dangerous, courts have had to focus instead on determining whether a type of firearm is unusual, often parsing marketing data and consumer surveys to gauge a weapon’s popularity.
A New York Times review found that courts have applied the “dangerous and unusual” test in at least 98 opinions in civil lawsuits that challenged weapons restrictions, most of them bankrolled by activist groups, since the 2008 Heller decision. In 20 of those rulings, the restrictions were overturned.
One example came in 2023. A federal judge in California noted the test’s wording when he struck down the state’s ban on assault weapons. “This court assumes that the Supreme Court does not use language frivolously, that it says what it means and it means what it says,” wrote Judge Roger Benitez.
The Supreme Court will revisit the issue when it hears oral arguments on Dec. 2 in a case that challenges assault-weapons bans in Illinois and Connecticut.
Gun-rights proponents have filed at least 14 briefs citing the “dangerous and unusual” test. Among their arguments is that there are more AR-15-type weapons in circulation than Ford F-series trucks, the most common pickups in America. That, they argue, proves that the guns, though dangerous, are not unusual.
To understand how the regulation of firearms turned into a popularity contest, we have to travel back to the age of Shakespeare.
William Lambarde “Eirenarcha”
William Hawkins “A Treatise of the Pleas of the Crown”
Kean Collection/Archive Photos, via Getty Images
In 1581, an English legal scholar, William Lambarde, published a judicial manual that referred in passing to troublemakers who were armed with “weapons not usually borne” — such as guns, which were far less common than they are today.
More than a century later, in 1716, a lawyer named William Hawkins coined the “dangerous and unusual” phrase, citing Lambarde’s manual as his source.
Fifty-three years later, Blackstone published his famous legal treatise, which mentioned “dangerous or unusual weapons.”
For the next two centuries, American judges and legal scholars used the two versions interchangeably when writing about laws regulating the possession and use of weapons, not placing importance on “and” versus “or.”
Then, in 2008, Justice Scalia wrote the Heller opinion and resuscitated the ancient “dangerous and unusual” language. He attributed it to, among others, Blackstone. The justice, like many other constitutional originalists, often turned to Blackstone as an authority on the prevalent legal thinking at the time the Constitution was written.
In another gun-related opinion in 2016, just a month after Justice Scalia died, Justice Samuel Alito amplified and sharpened the message. He placed a particular emphasis on the word “and.” Justice Alito asserted that Heller established “a conjunctive test: A weapon may not be banned unless it is both dangerous and unusual.”
In the years since, judges have overturned gun laws based on that conjunctive.
The test became even more prevalent after the Supreme Court’s 2022 rulingin New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, which folded the “dangerous and unusual” standard into a new process for evaluating the constitutionality of firearms restrictions.
Of the 98 civil cases in which federal and state judges applied the “dangerous and unusual” test, they upheld restrictions on guns and other weapons 68 times. They struck down laws on 20 occasions, and in another seven cases, they invalidated part of the laws. The rest are pending.
Each dot represents one opinion from a civil case challenging weapons restrictions. A case can appear more than once as it moves through the courts. By The New York Times
Justice Scalia embraced the “dangerous and unusual" language as he expanded the scope of the Second Amendment.
The amendment states: “A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.”
The Heller ruling declared, for the first time, that the amendment guaranteed an individual’s right to possess a gun, unconnected to militia service.
But that didn’t mean all restrictions on guns were unconstitutional: The government could impose limits on weapons that were not commonly used by civilians, Justice Scalia wrote. Such curbs were “fairly supported by the historical tradition of prohibiting the carrying of ‘dangerous and unusual weapons.’”
He cited a dozen sources for that quote. Blackstone was listed first, followed by a variety of 19th-century legal scholars and court opinions.
But half of those sources, including Blackstone, had used the phrase “dangerous or unusual.” The six that used “and” all cited Hawkins, the 18th-century barrister who was much less influential than Blackstone.
It is unclear whether Justice Scalia realized he was misquoting Blackstone — or if he simply didn't regard “and” versus “or” as an important distinction.
A few lower courts have noted the inaccuracy of his citation. Last year, a federal appeals court upheld Connecticut’s assault-weapons ban, saying it was in keeping with a tradition of restricting “unusually dangerous” weapons and explicitly rejecting the “dangerous and unusual” test that arose from Heller.
“It would seem a serious subversion of our commitment to history to enshrine a conjunctive test based on the Heller opinion’s possible misquote of Blackstone,” the appeals court said.
The Supreme Court is poised to review the constitutionality of Connecticut’s law.
Saul Cornell, a Second Amendment scholar and history professor at Fordham University, said relying on centuries-old legal precedents requires understanding how earlier generations used language. He said “dangerous and unusual” is most likely an example of hendiadys, in which a single concept is expressed in multiple words connected by “and.” One famous example of hendiadys is Shakespeare’s “full of sound and fury,” which meant furious sound.
“The best translation of Blackstone’s terminology,” Dr. Cornell said, “would be to treat ‘dangerous and unusual’ as a synonym for unusually dangerous.”
Tuesday, November 10, 2026
Thomas Massie Moves to Force Vote on Impeaching Pete Hegseth
Thomas Massie Moves to Force Vote on Impeaching Pete Hegseth
“Representative Thomas Massie initiated a House vote on eight impeachment articles against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, alleging constitutional and legal violations. Hegseth rejects the charges, and President Trump backs him. A House majority is required for impeachment, followed by a Senate trial.
Hegseth Impeachment Charges Say He Violated the Constitution
Representative Thomas Massie, Republican of Kentucky, set in motion a vote that must occur by Wednesday. If the House approves the charges, it will prompt a Senate trial.

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth could face an impeachment vote in the House as early as this week, as lawmakers return to Washington after an election in which voters delivered a sweeping rebuke of the Trump administration and the president’s handling of the war with Iran.
The effort is being led by Representative Thomas Massie, Republican of Kentucky, who on Monday called up a resolution accusing Mr. Hegseth of violating federal law and the Constitution, and abusing his authority on a number of fronts.
Democrats have signaled broad support for the effort, and several Republicans have expressed discontent with Mr. Hegseth, though the outcome remains uncertain in a narrowly divided House.
Here is what to know about the charges, the process and what could happen next.
The measure charges Mr. Hegseth with violating the Constitution.
Mr. Massie, who lost his primary in May to a challenger backed by President Trump, has introduced eight articles of impeachment against Mr. Hegseth, three of them focused on his conduct of the war with Iran.
The articles accuse the defense secretary of waging war without congressional authorization and continuing the military campaign after Congress voted to direct the president to terminate the conflict or seek authorization to continue it. The resolution also accuses Mr. Hegseth of violating deadlines under the War Powers Resolution, which requires the withdrawal of American forces from unauthorized hostilities after 60 days, with a possible 30-day extension.
The remaining charges accuse Mr. Hegseth of carrying out unlawful military strikes against suspected drug traffickers; unlawfully capturing Venezuela’s president, Nicolás Maduro; conducting unauthorized military operations in Yemen; disregarding laws intended to minimize civilian casualties; and abusing his power by retaliating against Senator Mark Kelly for protected speech.
It is up to Speaker Mike Johnson to decide whether the chamber will vote on each of the eight articles or if they will be considered as a package.
Mr. Hegseth has rejected the allegations, calling the impeachment effort a political sham. He is scheduled to hold a news conference on Tuesday morning to respond to the charges.
“Secretary Hegseth will not back down or be deterred by politicians seeking to score partisan points or launch phony investigations where no wrongdoing exists,” Sean Parnell, the Pentagon spokesman, said in a statement on Monday in which he said Mr. Hegseth intended to serve until the end of President Trump’s term.
Mr. Trump has backed his defense secretary and said he intends to keep Mr. Hegseth in his job.
A majority is required to impeach Mr. Hegseth.
The Constitution lays out the process for Congress to impeach and remove presidents, judges and other federal civil officers, including cabinet secretaries.
The first step is in the House, which considers articles of impeachment alleging treason, bribery or other high crimes and misdemeanors. A simple majority is required to approve any article. Impeachment amounts to a formal accusation by Congress, which is then sent to the Senate for a trial to determine whether the official should be convicted and removed from office.
House rules allow any member to propose impeachment articles and require that the body consider them within two legislative days. Congressional leaders — in this case Republicans — have no power to block a vote, but they can try to head off the impeachment by either moving to send the charges to a committee, delaying final action, or to table them, which would effectively kill the effort.
If the House were to impeach Mr. Hegseth, it would take a two-thirds vote of senators present to convict and remove him.
The outcome of the impeachment vote is uncertain.
Democrats are widely expected to support impeaching Mr. Hegseth, and Representative Hakeem Jeffries, the minority leader, declared on Sunday that he was a “hard yes.” With Republicans holding a razor-thin majority, as few as three Republican defections or a few absences could be enough to put the resolution over the top.
Apart from Mr. Massie, several Republicans have expressed frustration with the secretary without committing to impeachment. Representative French Hill, Republican of Arkansas, said Sunday that he wanted to hear the arguments but cautioned that poor performance alone did not necessarily constitute an impeachable offense.
“I don’t know if we have enough votes,” Mr. Massie told reporters on Monday. “I’m doing this because it’s the right thing to do.”
Beyond the political calculations, many lawmakers are considering whether policy decisions ordered by the president warrant impeachment. When House Republicans impeached Alejandro Mayorkas, who served as the homeland security secretary under President Joseph R. Biden Jr., over his handling of immigration enforcement, Democrats opposed the charges, arguing that policy choices did not constitute impeachable offenses. The Republican-led House impeached Mr. Mayorkas, but the Senate dismissed the charges.
There is no fixed timeline for impeachment.
If the House were to impeach Mr. Hegseth, he would remain defense secretary while the articles were pending, and it would be up to House leaders to decide when to send the matter to the Senate for a trial.
Unlike legislation, however, impeachment resolutions do not die at the end of a Congress, so Democrats, who will control the House and Senate starting Jan. 3, would be able to take up the matter when they assume power.
Eric Schmitt contributed reporting.”